Weak muscles lead to bad posture. So why doesn’t a gym workout help?
Weak muscles lead to bad posture. So why doesn't a gym workout help? If you have chronic back or neck problems, you almost certainly have bad posture, though it may not be certain which came first. Nevertheless, you will often hear (or get) advice that you need to strengthen your postural muscle and correct your posture.
And after months of hard work at the gym with weights and cable machines, you feel slightly better but you still slouch now and then. Why didn't it work fully for perfect posture ALL the time?
The reason gym workouts fail to completely correct and support your posture all the time, is that it simply did not target all the relevant muscles – the stability muscles. And it was the wrong type of training for some of the muscles – gym works targets the power muscles. And muscles exercises alone isn't enough – postural awareness is also required.
What are the different types of muscles and why does the differences matter?
We tend to think of muscles as simply muscles but in fact, there are broadly two basic muscle types – striated muscles (that includes those postural muscles) and smooth muscles.
- Striated muscles are your skeletal muscles. Muscles that you usually think of such as your bicep muscle or calf muscle.Your heart muscle is also a type of striated muscle but stands distinct from the rest of the skeletal muscle.
- Smooth muscles are usually involuntary muscle that blends in other tissue type to form say your bladder or intestines.
Longer weaker, Shorter stronger
One key difference between striated and smooth muscles is that the strength of the striated muscle weakens the further it is stretched apart. So the same muscle, at say, 10cm length will exert a lot of more force at both ends as it contracts then if the same muscle is stretch to, say, 20cm. More specifically the strength of the muscle is a function of the area of its cross-section – the fatter, the strong the muscle.
Smooth muscle is different is this respect. It doesn't lose its strength as it gets stretched out. An important feature to have with a full bladder or stomach.
So now we know that skeletal muscle, a type of striated muscle, is weaker when it is stretched and stronger when it is shortened. What does this mean to people with bad posture?
It means that one of the key things to do to strengthen weak posture muscles it to shorten the lengthened ones and lengthen the shortened ones. That is get your posture right to strengthen the key postural muscles and to release to the overly tight/strong muscles that is pulling you out of the right posture.
Sustaining good posture and strengthening the postural muscles is further confused by how we think about muscle strengthening programmes. To build strong muscles, we generally think about more repetitions, heavier weights and repeat as required. This works if we are talking about big power muscles such as your biceps and thigh muscles. Postural muscles have a higher percentage of Type I (slow twitch) fibres. These are fibres that are designed for endurance, not power.
This means for slow twitch fibres, a better type of exercises is one where we use lower load threshold and holding it for longer periods of time. Again, it sounds exactly like holding the right posture for prolonged periods of time (with proper rest periods in between) will improve your posture over time.
When a movement is loaded with too heavy a load, the fast twitch (Type II) muscle fibres take over.This is one of the reason why lower load exercises like pilates and yoga are better for people with low back problems than heavy workouts at the gym.
|Fiber Type||Type I fibers||Type II a fibers||Type II x fibers||Type II b fibers|
|Contraction time||Slow||Moderately Fast||Fast||Very fast|
|Size of motor neuron||Small||Medium||Large||Very large|
|Resistance to fatigue||High||Fairly high||Intermediate||Low|
|Activity Used for||Aerobic||Long-term anaerobic||Short-term anaerobic||Short-term anaerobic|
|Maximum duration of use||Hours||<30 minutes||<5 minutes||<1 minute|
|Power produced||Low||Medium||High||Very high|
|Major storage fuel||Triglycerides||Creatine phosphate, glycogen||Creatine phosphate, glycogen||Creatine phosphate, glycogen|
|Myosin heavy chain,|