Neck Pain: The Truth On Traction
The amount of people working in a desk bound jobs is increasing worldwide. Unfortunately, these jobs tend to go hand-in-hand with a greater chance of suffering from prolonged neck and back pain. Maybe for this very reason, currently the most common source of musculoskeletal disability is chronic neck pain.
Case Study 1
According to a recent study, 34% of the general population experiences neck pain at some time in their life. 14% of this number have symptoms lasting longer than six months.
Due to the number of health care visits, work absenteeism, decreased productivity and disability, neck pain has huge consequences on people’s well being and their health care expenses.
Traction For Neck Pain
There are many methods that clinicians use to treat neck pain. A traditional and conservative method commonly used by physiotherapists is cervical traction. Despite its clinical popularity, previous and current studies, looking at the effectiveness of cervical traction, remain inconclusive.
Impacts Of Traction
In theory, applying a controlled pulling force on the spine causes a number of physiological effects:
– Enlarges the intervertebral foramen
– Releases pressure on intervertebral discs
– It releases pressure on nerve roots and blood vessels
– Stretched ligaments and paravertebral muscles of the neck region
– Reduction in effects of abnormalities of the cervical facet joints
A release of muscle tension, nerve tension, and increased blood circulation in the cervical region are expected. This would ultimately result in decrease neck pain.
Case Study 2
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University investigated intermittent cervical traction on 79 patients with chronic neck pain in a more recent study. The patients were placed into two groups at random, and are aged between 20 to 70 years old. For a period of six weeks, one group received cervical traction twice a week, adminsistered by a experienced senior physiotherapist. The second group received placebo- infra-red (heat therapy) treatment twice a week.
The patients were to complete a disability questionnaire after a 6 weeks and also a 3 months interval. They were to score their pain on a scale. Their also measured their range of motion of the cervical spine.
From this study they concluded that there was no significant difference in disability, pain and range of motion between the group that received traction, and the group receiving the placebo infrared treatment. The researchers did state that there were several limitations to the study.
Several other studies in the past have found similar findings that as a treatment method in soltaion, traction does not show significant improvements. Research supporting its benefits and use is somewhat flawed or inconclusive. More methodological randomised control studies should thus be carried out.
In order to maximize the benefit of treatment for patients with chronic neck pain, it is important for clinicians to consider giving a combined and individualized treatment to them instead, of intermittent cervical traction alone. Studies of late are generally leaning to a combined approach of exercise therapy, education, joint mobilisation and manipulations as being the most effective method of treating neck pain
Experiencing neck pain? Click here to find out more about physiotherapy for neck pain relief and how Core Concepts can help
Chiu, T.T., Ng, J.K., Walther-Zhang, B., Lin, R.J.H., Ortelli, L., Kuan, S (2011) A randomized controlled trial on the efficacy of intermittent cervical traction for patients with chronic neck pain; Clinical Rehabilitation:1–9
Related Articles That You May Find Interesting
Popular Articles That You May Find Interesting
- Snapping Ankle - Physiotherapy
- Labour Epidural Cause Chronic Backache?
- The Best Exercises for Trochanteric Bursitis
- Posterior Pelvic Pain (Sacroiliac Joint Pain) in Pregnant Women
- How do I know if I have scoliosis?
- Diastasis Recti Abdominis - Conditions
- Cobb Angle and Scoliosis
- Maybe it isn't Plantar Fasciitis but Heel Fat Pad Syndrome
- What to do when your back hurts so much that you can't get out of bed?
- Multifidus - Smallest Yet Most Powerful Muscle
- Nerve Stretches
- Shoulder Pain - Frequently Asked Questions
- 'Clunking' Shoulders - Part I
- Waking up with neck pain? Find the right pillow.
- Not All Pain In the Back Is Back Pain - It Could Be Rib Pain
- MCL strain not getting better? Because it is Pes Ancerinus Tendinitis.
- Slipped Disc in Singapore - What to Do and Avoid
- Better to break a bone than to tear a ligament or tendon
- Knee Joint & Ankle Pain - Specialist Treatment in Singapore
- Acromion Clavicle Joint - Another source of shoulder pain
- Sway Back No More
- Knock Knees - Can I reverse it? (Part 1)
- Sway back posture: A leading poor posture type causing back pain
- Posterior Capsule stretches